Birgitt Haas Must Be Killed

Birgitt Haas Must Be Killed
Birgitt Haas Must Be Killed
Directed by	Laurent Heynemann
Written by	Pierre Fabre; Laurent Heynemann; Caroline Huppert ;
Based on	L'histoire de Birgitt Haas by Guy Teisseire
Produced by	Jean-Serge Breton ; Yves Gasser
Starring	Philippe Noiret; Jean Rochefort; Lisa Kreuzer;
Cinematography	Jean-Francis Gondre
Music by	Philippe Sarde
Production; companies	Films A2 ; Zénith Production
Release date	2 September 1981;
Running time	105 minutes
Countries	France ; West Germany
Language	French

Birgitt Haas Must Be Killed (French: Il faut tuer Birgitt Haas) is a 1981 French-West German political thriller film directed by Laurent Heynemann and starring Philippe Noiret, Jean Rochefort and Lisa Kreuzer.^[1] It is based on the novel L'histoire de Birgitt Haas by Guy Teisseire.

Plot

Athanase, head of a top-secret counterintelligence group called "Hangar", is given the task of eliminating Birgitt Haas, a former German terrorist. A new ambitious member of the group, Colonna, suggests disguising the assassination as a crime of passion by connecting Birgitt with a random man who would later take the blame for the murder. For this role, Colonna suggests Bauman, an unemployed, weak-willed man whose wife left him. Bauman's ex-wife happens to be Colonna's mistress. Upon his arrival in Munich, Bauman meets Birgitt, falls in love with her and plans to go away with her. Athanase's group proceeds with their assassination plan, but Bauman intervenes. In the ensuing shootout, Colonna is mortally wounded by Birgitt who then surrenders to the police.

Cast

Philippe Noiret as Athanase
Jean Rochefort as Charles-Philippe Bauman
Lisa Kreuzer as Monica / Birgitt Haas
Bernard Le Coq as Colonna
Maurice Teynac as Chamrode
Michel Beaune as Delaunay
Victor Garrivier as Nader
Monique Chaumette as Laura
Christian Bouillette
Stephan Meldegg as Steinhof
Peter Chatel as Betz
Roland Blanche as Othenin
Dagmar Deisen as Gisella
Lucienne Hamon as Claire, la femme d'Athanase
Axel Ganz as Weidman

Reception

The film was only moderately successful in France and sold 949,556 tickets.^[2]

It received mixed reviews in the U.S. Vincent Canby in The New York Times called it "an espionage melodrama of startling ineptitude" and "a movie of wrong-headed solemnity."^[3] The Washington Post criticized Heynemann and his screenwriting collaborators for approaching "a shaky thriller premise in the guise of rank, soggy-sleeved sentimentalists", and added that the film "would be substantially improved if it took a cold-eyed view of its characters."^[4] The Christian Science Monitor said it was "resonant and involving much of the time, but slippery and superficial in its refusal to take a forthright stand on the issue of terrorism itself."^[5] Stanley Kauffmann in The New Republic said the film hit "the double bull's eye".^[6] In WOR-TV & The New York Journal, Judith Crist called it "an eerie, fantastic tale of undercover intrigue", and added that "three stunning performances--by Philippe Noiret, Jean Rochefort and Lisa Kreuzer--give credibility and power." Bay Area Reporter called it "a good thriller, and more compassionate than most", and concluded: "this is decidedly not one of those spy films in which people are no more than numbers; even minor characters are fleshed out into human form."^[7]

References

^ Rège p.45
^ "Jean Rochefort Box Office". Box Office Story. Retrieved 2019-09-18.
^ Canby, Vincent (1982-08-20). "Birgitt Haas Must Be Killed". New York Times. Retrieved 2019-09-18.
^ Arnold, Gary (1982-11-12). "Sanctimonious Spies". Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286. Retrieved 2019-09-19.
^ "Monthly Movie Guide". Christian Science Monitor. 1982-09-16. ISSN 0882-7729. Retrieved 2019-09-18.
^ Kauffmann, Stanley (1982-08-30). "On Films: Garp's World and Others". The New Republic: 26–27.
^ Warren, Steve (1982-11-18). "Spies are People Too". Bay Area Reporter. 12: 26 – via archive.org.