Shutler was part of Loudoun FC's 98B Red side, before playing college soccer at the University of Virginia. Shutler redshirted the 2016 season, before going on to make 45 appearances for the Cavaliers, registering 24 shutouts, a 0.68 Goals Against Average rating as well as an 81% save percentage. Shutler also became the first Cavalier goalkeeper to earn first-team all-Atlantic Coast Conference honors since Tony Meola in 1989.[1]
On March 9, 2024, Shulter scored a stoppage time game-tying goal against Sacramento Republic FC, becoming the first Orange County goalkeeper to score a goal.[citation needed]
References
^"Colin Shutler". Virginia Cavaliers Official Athletic Site. April 28, 2020.