"Darkness" has received mixed critical responses given its explicit content. U.S. news service The Atlantic stated in an article that it can be alternately assessed as glorifying gun violence and also as fighting against it, with journalist Spencer Kornhaber arguing that Eminem's deliberate embodying of the mass shooter's point-of-view throughout "Darkness" made it ethically flawed overall.[4] Commentary on Billboard.com described the release as "powerful" and also labeled Eminem with the title of a "Rap God".[3]CNN.com published an article regarding the song as "a poignant call for expanded gun control", noting the broader context of the artist's "outspoken" past ventures into U.S. politics such as criticizing the invasion of Iraq and other violent actions undertaken by then PresidentGeorge W. Bush in the 2000s.[1]
Background and content
Commentator Eddie Fu, a staff writer at the musical publication Genius, wrote: "The track channels the perspective of Stephen Paddock— who killed 60 people in the 2017 Las Vegas shooting— to make a point about gun control."[2] Journalist Spencer Kornhaber noted for The Atlantic: "The song and the video do not simply restage the massacre, though. Eminem is attempting a double entendre, in which most of the lyrics could equally refer to the rapper himself, sitting in a hotel room, nervous before a concert."[4]
The outro explicitly references other violent incidents beyond what happened in Las Vegas, Nevada, particularly noting the headline-making attacks in both Annapolis, Maryland and Dayton, Ohio.[2] As well, the opening section of "Darkness" brings up the history of the city in popular culture. Eminem raps that he "[f]eels like I’m loathing in Las Vegas",[2] with this referring to the countercultural writing Fear And Loathing In Las Vegas and its movie adaptation.
"Darkness" interpolates the song "The Sound of Silence" by American musical duo Simon & Garfunkel, which had appeared on that group's 1964 album Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M. The prior track's opening line, which goes "Hello, darkness, my old friend", also is prominently emphasized in Eminem's song.[2]
Music video
On January 17, 2020, a music video of the song was released on Eminem's YouTube channel. The video follows the same plot as the lyrics. The first two verses alternate between showing Eminem in a dark room wearing a hoodie and an unidentified person in a hotel room wearing the same hoodie, surrounded by alcohol and ammunition. At the beginning of the third verse, the person takes off the hood and reveals himself to be the Las Vegas shooter, before opening fire on the concert-goers from the hotel window. As police try to break into his room, the shooter, instead of opening fire at the front door, shoots himself in the head.
The video ends with overlapping news feeds regarding gun violence, and the closing message: "When will it end? When enough people care. Register to vote at vote.gov. Make your voice heard and help change the gun laws in America."
As of January 2024, the music video has over 63 million views.
Reactions and responses
"Darkness" has received mixed responses from music critics and other commentators given its explicit content. U.S. news service The Atlantic stated in an article that it can be alternately assessed as glorifying gun violence and also as fighting against it. With journalist Spencer Kornhaber arguing that Eminem's deliberate embodying of the mass shooter's point-of-view throughout "Darkness" made it ethically flawed overall, the publication highlighted a negative social context given that "the internet rewards audiovisual spectacle" and thus reenacting crimes in a dramatic fashion has nuanced effects.[4]
Commentary on Billboard.com described the release as "powerful" and also labeled Eminem with the title of a "Rap God".[3]CNN.com published an article regarding the song as "a poignant call for expanded gun control", noting the broader context of the artist's "outspoken" past ventures into U.S. politics. This has included criticizing the invasion of Iraq and other violent actions undertaken by then PresidentGeorge W. Bush in the 2000s.[1]
Analyzing the music video specifically, its filmmaking style has been described as "realistic" and involving a production that appears "disturbing for some viewers".[1]
^"ČNS IFPI" (in Czech). Hitparáda – Digital Top 100 Oficiální. IFPI Czech Republic. Note: Change the chart to CZ – SINGLES DIGITAL – TOP 100 and insert 202004 into search. Retrieved January 28, 2020.
^"ČNS IFPI" (in Slovak). Hitparáda – Singles Digital Top 100 Oficiálna. IFPI Czech Republic. Note: Select SINGLES DIGITAL - TOP 100 and insert 202004 into search. Retrieved January 28, 2020.