Banff National Park Pavilion

Banff National Park Pavilion
Banff National Park Pavilion
	The Pavilion, circa 1920
Alternative names	Frank Lloyd Wright Pavilion
General information
Type	Public pavilion
Architectural style	Prairie School
Coordinates	51°10′25″N 115°34′46″W / 51.173720°N 115.579326°W
Construction started	Designed 1911; Construction 1913
Completed	1914
Demolished	1939
Cost	CAD$20000; $40000 (estimated 1913); $100000 (speculated 1964)
Client	Public Works and Government Services Canada
Dimensions
Other dimensions	200ft x 50ft
Technical details
Floor count	Single
Design and construction
Architect(s)	Frank Lloyd Wright; Francis Conroy Sullivan
Main contractor	Bennett, Debman, & Co.

The Banff National Park Pavilion, was designed by Frank Lloyd Wright and Francis Conroy Sullivan, one of Wright's only Canadian students. Designed in 1911, in the Prairie School style, construction began in 1913 and was completed the following year. The pavilion was built on the Recreation Grounds near the south end of the Bow River Bridge on the edge of the town of Banff, itself located within Banff National Park in Alberta. The last of only two Wright designs in Canada, the pavilion was demolished in 1938.^[8]

History

Banff National Park had been established in 1885 as Banff Hot Springs Reserve. Expanded in 1887 as Rocky Mountains Park under the Rocky Mountains Park Act the area became the first national park in Canada, and the second in North America behind Yellowstone. As a national park the controlling authority became the Federal Government of Canada, rather than the province of Alberta.

Sullivan, unrelated to Wright's previous employer Louis Sullivan, had worked in Wright's Oak Park Studio^[7] before leaving for Ottawa in 1908 to work for the government as an architect for, as it was then known, the Department of Public Works.

By the 1900s Banff National Park, as it had become known, was increasing in popularity and, by 1911, had become accessible by automobile. A visitor pavilion was commissioned by government officials in Ottawa.^[6] A concept plan had been submitted by residents of Banff to Ottawa, but officials rejected it. Envisioning a more refined structure^[9] Wright and Sullivan were hired. The building contract was awarded to Bennett, Debman, & Co., of Calgary^[2] who aimed to use local labour and purchase building supplies from local merchants.^[2]

After completion, in 1914 during World War I, the pavilion was used as a Quartermaster's store by the Department of National Defence.^[6] After the War the main function of the pavilion became a gathering area for tourists waiting on trains.^[6]

Wright and Sullivan worked together on four built projects. While the Banff National Park Pavilion is attributed to Wright with Sullivan's assistance, the other three are attributed to Sullivan with Wright's assistance.^[7]

Design

The pavilion featured a rustic style over a frame construction,^[6] and was an elongated visitor shelter of wood and stone.^[1] Supported by low stone walls^[7] the length of the building was constructed of wood, in a board-and-batten fashion.^[7] Steel beams supported the cantilevered roof.^[7]

The interior was primarily an assembly lounge 100 ft by 50 ft in size.^[6] A row of art glass windows^[1] ran the entire length of the wall opposite the main entrance, and three cobblestone^[6] fireplaces featured on the remaining three.^[7] Clerestory windows contributed additional light,^[7] through the exposed beams of the roof.

A ladies' powder room was at one end of the lounge, with a gentlemen's retiring room at the other.^[1] Each room measured 50 ft by 25 ft.^[6] The pavilion also featured public lockers.^[6]

The finished product was only usable four months of the year, suitable only for a few summer sports, and as a picnickers' lounging area.^[3]

Similar in design to the River Forest Tennis Club, in River Forest, Illinois,^[7] the pavilion is also considered comparable to the Lake Geneva Hotel, in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, also designed in 1911 and itself demolished in 1970.^[10]

Destruction

Built on the shore of the Bow River, on swampy ground, the pavilion was subject to flooding,^[11] severe frost,^[6] and consequent decay.

The Banff Crag and Canyon reported in July 1920 that;

"The grounds in front of the recreation building were under water last week, and it was possible for a man, if so inclined, to wade out to the building, sit on the steps and fish."^[4]

The pavilion suffered severe flood damage in 1933,^[6] and deterioration progressed to the point that the building was torn down in 1938.^[8]^[7] Ruins of the pavilion were visible until the early 1960s, but by 1965 all traces had been washed away or sunk into the bog.^[6]

Controversy

During its life residents saw the building as a symbol of Ottawa's contempt for their concerns.^[11] Wanting a building designed for local recreational needs,^[11] the original and unused plans included areas for curling and ice hockey,^[3] calling for a building that could be used year-round. Those plans were overseen by locals and approved by Banff residents after a public meeting at the National Park Theatre.^[3] In December 1913, just months after construction began the Banff Crag and Canyon reported that;

"....their wishes and desires were, as usual, ignored by the 'overlords' at Ottawa, who imagine they are wiser as to the conditions in Banff than those who live and have their being here."^[3]

Years later, in July 1920, the Banff Crag and Canyon reported of the building and grounds that;

"They are neither ornamental nor useful—except as a standing monument to the incapacity of Parks Commissioner Harkin."^[4]

Nevertheless, the building was reasonably popular with local residents, and in the last thirty years, interest has grown in the structure and Wright's short-lived career and legacy in Canada.

References

^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Whyte Museum of the Canadian Rockies, page 1, at www.archivesalberta.org
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g Banff Crag and Canyon, October 18, 1913, at www.archivesalberta.org
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f Banff Crag and Canyon, December 16, 1913, at www.archivesalberta.org
^ ^a ^b ^c Banff Crag and Canyon, July 10, 1920, at www.archivesalberta.org
^ FLW design timeline
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h ⁱ ^j ^k ^l Banff Crag and Canyon, December 16, 1964, at www.archivesalberta.org
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h ⁱ ^j William A Storrer, The Architecture of Frank Lloyd Wright, p.167, University of Chicago Press; 2002
^ ^a ^b Banff Crag & Canyon January 21, 1938
^ Brian R. Sinclair and Terence J. Walker, "Frank Lloyd Wright's Banff Pavilion: Critical Inquiry and Virtual Reconstruction", APT Bulletin, p. 13, Vol. 28, No. 2/3, 1997, at www.jstor.org
^ Robert C. Twombly, Frank Lloyd Wright: His Life and His Architecture, p.157, Wiley-Interscience; 1987.
^ ^a ^b ^c Whyte Museum of the Canadian Rockies, page 2, at www.archivesalberta.org