In his first season as quarterback for the Bearcats, Moore threw for 1,885 yards, helping the Bearcats secure third place in their conference.[3] 2016 saw Moore play as starting QB for the first time, where he threw for 1,744, an effort that was only enough for Cinicnnati to reach 4th in the division.[4] 2017 was a breakout year for Moore; however, he was unable to convert his exemplary stats into wins for the Bearcats, with Cininnati finishing the season with only 4 wins.[5]
On May 2, 2019, Moore signed with the Hamilton Tiger-Cats as their third-string quarterback.[7] He played during Week 2 of the CFL Preseason, playing the second half against the Ottawa Redblacks. Moore threw 176 yards and 2 touchdowns to win the game for Hamilton.[8] Moore also played the last 8 minutes of Hamilton's Week 3 Preseason game against the Toronto Argonauts, throwing for 30 yards with 57% efficiency; however, Moore's efforts were not enough to overcome the Argos' defence, and the Ticats lost the game 30-23.[9] He re-signed with the Tiger-Cats on January 7, 2021.[10] He retired from football on June 28, 2021.[11]