John Balfour of Kinloch

John Balfour of Kinloch
John Balfour of Kinloch
	John Balfour (fl. 1663–1683)
Nationality	Scottish
Other names	Burly
Movement	Covenanters
Spouse	Barbara Hackston
Criminal charge	murder
Reward amount	10,000 merks
Details
Victims	James Sharp
Date	3 May 1679

John Balfour of Kinloch was the principal actor in the assassination of Archbishop Sharp in 1679.^[1]^[5] For this crime his estate was forfeited and a large reward offered for his capture. He fought at Drumclog and at Bothwell Bridge, and is said to have escaped to Holland, and to have there tendered his services to the Prince of Orange.^[6]^[5]

Early life and legal problems

Among the hearers of the field-preachers in Fife, in the summer of 1672, was 'John Balfour, portioner in Kinloch,' in the parish of Collessie.^[7] He was reportedly a squat, squint-eyed, fierce-looking man, and was known as 'Burly'. He disobeyed the order of the court to compear and answer for conventicling, for which contempt of court he was under warrant for arrest. Balfour's brother-in-law, David Hackston, proprietor of Rathillet, in Kilmany parish, succeeded his father in 1670.' He was esteemed a gallant country gentleman, at first of the prelatic party, and having employment of some kind from Rothes.^[7]

Early in October 1667, the outlawed John Balfour of Kinloch stole home to meet his friend and neighbour, Alexander Hamilton of Kinkel, Robert Hamilton, son of Sir Thomas Hamilton of Preston, and other conventiclers. Captain Carstairs and a dozen troopers rode up to capture the meeting. A boisterous Irish soldier, called Garret, took a trial shot, to which the defenders replied by a volley which brought down Garret and put his comrades to flight.^[8]

Account of Sharp's killing

In 1678, Sharp's faction regained control and supported by the government, stepped up actions against non-conformists; 3,000 Lowland militia and 6,000 Highlanders, known as the "Highland Host", were billeted in the Covenanting shires, as a form of punishment. James Mitchell, who had been arrested in 1673, was executed in 1678, making him a Presbyterian folk hero; Sharp gave evidence at his trial and was accused of perjury.^[9]

On 3 May 1679, a group of nine Covenanters, led by David Hackston and his brother-in-law, John Balfour of Kinloch, were waiting at Magus Muir, hoping to ambush the Sheriff of Cupar.^[10] A Sharp appointee, the Sheriff was prominent in persecuting Covenanters but apparently heard about the proposed ambush and stayed home.^[11] Learning Sharp's coach was on the road, they intercepted it instead; Sharp was stabbed several times, in front of his daughter Isabella, before being killed by a shot to the chest. One of the group, James Russell, claimed he told Sharp he "...declared before the Lord that it was no particular interest, nor yet for any wrong that he had done to him, but because he had betrayed the church as Judas, and had wrung his hands, these 18 or 19 years in the blood of the saints, but especially at Pentland..."^[12]

Two of the nine, Hackston and Andrew Guillan, were eventually captured and executed; a third, William Dingwall, died at the Battle of Drumclog a month later.^[9] The other six were never tried; Balfour escaped to Holland with George Fleming, but disappears from the records thereafter.^[1]

Death

It is generally supposed that John Balfour of Burley died at sea on a return voyage to Scotland. But in the New Statistical Account of Scotland, under "Roseneath", strong presumptions are stated for believing that he never left Scotland, but found an asylum in the parish of Roseneath, Dumbartonshire, under the wing of the Argyll family. According to this account, having assumed the name of Salter, his descendants continued there for many generations, the last of the family dying in 1815.^[13] Scott noted in his Old Mortality that in 1808 a Lieutenant-Colonel Balfour de Burleigh was commandant of the troops of the King of Holland in the West Indies.^[6]^[5]^[7] Hewison says: "Among the exiles who perished abroad was John Balfour of Kinloch, said to have been drowned on his return from Holland. But accounts differ as to the fate of this fugitive, and nothing certain is known of his last deeds and days."^[14]^[1]

Family

John Balfour of Kinloch, was the son of John Balfour and Grizzel Hay, daughter of Hay of Paris, Perthshire, born c. 1640. John served heir to his grandfather Robert, 26 February 1663. John Balfour of Kinloch married Barbara Hackston, sister of David Hackston of Rathillet. His confiscated property went to Lord Lindores: Scot. Mag., i. 130 (September 1817)^[7]

Walter Scott's character

Another man Lord Balfour of Burleigh has been traditionally styled "Covenanter", which he assuredly never was. On Sir Walter Scott must be laid the blame — if blame it be — by having appropriated the name and designation in his "John Balfour of Burley" in Old Mortality.^[5]

References

Citations

^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Muir 2004.
^ Macleod 2009.
^ Wodrow 1829, [1].
^ Hewison 1913, 283.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Grosart 1885, p. 55.
^ ^a ^b Anderson 1877, p. 211.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Hewison 1913, 252.
^ Hewison 1913, p265.
^ ^a ^b Mullan 2004.
^ Jardine 2018.
^ "Magus Muir Memorial". Findagrave.com.
^ Russell of Kettle 1817, p. 396.
^ Story 1845.
^ Hewison 1913, 512fn.

Other sources

"Balfour's Bible". Glenbow Library and Archives: Garnet Joseph Wolseley Fonds. University of Calgary.
Brown, P. Hume, ed. (1912). The register of the Privy Council of Scotland. 3. Vol. 6 1678/1680. Edinburgh: Published By The Authority Of The Lords Commissioners Of His Majesty's Treasury, Under The Direction Of The Deputy Clerk Register Of Scotland. H.M. General Register House.
Crookshank, William (1812a). The history of the state and sufferings of the Church of Scotland, from the Restoration to the Revolution. With an introd., containing the most remarkable occurrences relating to that Church from the Reformation. Vol. 1. Edinburgh: Thomas Turnbull. p. 332 et passim.
Crookshank, William (1812b). The history of the state and sufferings of the Church of Scotland, from the Restoration to the Revolution. With an introd., containing the most remarkable occurrences relating to that Church from the Reformation. Vol. 2. Edinburgh: Thomas Turnbull. pp. 142 et passim.
Jardine, Mark (21 June 2018). "The Torn Bible of the Covenanter and Assassin Balfour at RUSI". Jardine's Book of Martyrs. Retrieved 12 April 2019.
Johnston, John C. (1887). Treasury of the Scottish covenant. Andrew Elliot. pp. 348, 375, 597.
Macleod, Donald (2009). "The influence of Calvinism on politics". Theology in Scotland. 16 (2): 5-22.
M'Crie, Thomas (1857). M'Crie, Thomas (ed.). Works of Thomas M'Crie, D.D. Volume 4: review of "Tales of my Landlord". Vol. 4. Edinburgh: William Blackwood & sons. pp. 10, 70.
Muir, Alison G. (2004). "Balfour, John, of Kinloch". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/67514. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
Mullan, David George (2004). "Sharp, James". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/25211. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
Russell of Kettle, James (1817). James Russell's Account of the murder of Archbishop Sharp 1679. J. Ballantyne. pp. 410 et sequi.
Smellie, Alexander (1903). "A May Day on Magus Muir". Men of the Covenant: the story of the Scottish church in the years of the Persecution (2 ed.). New York: Fleming H. Revell Co. pp. 1-12.
Story, Robert (1845). The new statistical account of Scotland. Vol. 8. Edinburgh and London: W. Blackwood and Sons. p. 116.
Wodrow, Robert (1830). Burns, Robert (ed.). The history of the sufferings of the church of Scotland from the restoration to the revolution, with an original memoir of the author, extracts from his correspondence, and preliminary dissertation and notes, in four volumes. Vol. 2. Glasgow: Blackie Fullerton & Co. pp. 371 et passim.
Wodrow, Robert (1829). Burns, Robert (ed.). The history of the sufferings of the church of Scotland from the restoration to the revolution, with an original memoir of the author, extracts from his correspondence, and preliminary dissertation and notes, in four volumes. Vol. 3. Glasgow: Blackie Fullerton & Co. pp. 47 et passim.
Wodrow, Robert (1835). Burns, Robert (ed.). The history of the sufferings of the church of Scotland from the restoration to the revolution, with an original memoir of the author, extracts from his correspondence, and preliminary dissertation and notes, in four volumes. Vol. 4. Glasgow: Blackie Fullerton & Co. pp. 532 et passim.

Attribution

Anderson, William (1877). "Balfour". The Scottish nation: or, The surnames, families, literature, honours, and biographical history of the people of Scotland. Vol. 1. A. Fullarton & co. pp. 211. This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
Grosart, Alexander Balloch (1885). "Balfour, John" . In Stephen, Leslie (ed.). Dictionary of National Biography. Vol. 3. London: Smith, Elder & Co. p. 55. This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
Hewison, James King (1913). The Covenanters. Vol. 2. Glasgow: John Smith and son. pp. 252 et passim. This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
Howie, John (1870). "John Balfour of Kinloch". In Carslaw, W. H. (ed.). The Scots worthies. Edinburgh: Oliphant, Anderson, & Ferrier. pp. 622–623.
M'Crie, Thomas (1846). Sketches of Scottish church history : embracing the period from the Reformation to the Revolution. Vol. 2. Edinburgh: J. Johnstone. p. 157. This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
Thomson, J. H. (1903). Hutchison, Matthew (ed.). The martyr graves of Scotland. Edinburgh: Oliphant, Anderson & Ferrier. p. 188 et passim. This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.